Showing posts with label Advanced Access project. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Advanced Access project. Show all posts

Saturday, July 12, 2008

Healthy skepticism

Latest Adventures in Improved Access post.

Read More......

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

Welcome to Strategy readers!

Plain Brown Wrapper is mentioned in this quarter's Strategy, the CMA's financial management magazine. If the Strategy article led you here, thanks for coming. Have a look around the site. I have the most fun with "What's wrong with this picture".

Also, I'm very excited about our office's ongoing Advanced Access project (latest post here), chronicled at Health Quality Council's website. We're trying to reduce patient wait times in our 9-physician urology group.

Read More......

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Culture change

Latest Advanced Access post "Culture Change" AKA Phase I complete!

Read More......

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Oh, the irony!

I've been quite liberal in my derision of poor Powerpoint presentations. But Mr. Smarty-Pants stepped in it big-time this week.

I appreciate an excellent presentation. At meetings or rounds, I really enjoy a speaker who has taken the time to put his/her audience first. Who makes sure the audiovisual material is appealing and appropriate. Who checks that all the necessary equipment is available and functional.

I like to give a good presentation. And I cringe when something goes wrong. Like earlier this week.

I was invited to present our Advanced Access project to the annual meeting of the Saskatchewan Association of Health Organizations in Regina. I was excited to be asked and put a lot of work into the presentation.

I used lots of graphics and photos, and kept text to a minimum. (Only one bullet point slide out of 42!) I stuck to 3 main points. I included some video clips to illustrate my points.

And that's where the wheels came off the wagon.

There was no speaker system to amplify the sound from my laptop. It wasn't a big room, but people at the back couldn't hear the clips. What better way to have your audience's attention wander?

To make it worse, one of the themes of my presentation was "It's all about your audience". I was trying to apply the metaphor of a performer and his audience to the concept of patient and family-centred care in our Advanced Access project. I went on and on about how important it is to think about what engages and entertains your audience (or what's important for your patient). Then, I play the video clips and half the audience can't hear them.

Just to balance my karma, another theme was "Do it", meaning, don't be afraid to try new things and fail at them, because it's always a chance to learn from mistakes. This was the first time I'd included a lot of video clips, so it was a nice demonstration of how to screw up when you try something new. Irony was having a field day.

My first inclination was to blame the conference organizers. I'd given them plenty of notice that I needed to plug into an audio system, but nothing was provided. But, I have to take responsibility myself. I've often seen speakers stymied when they couldn't get a computer or projector going, and thought "That's pathetic that you are so reliant on your slides to speak about this topic. You should be prepared for tech glitches." It was my turn to be stymied.

For next time, I'll have to see about getting a small, portable speaker that I can connect to my laptop. Oh, geez, I just had an esprit de l'escalier moment: I should have taken off my lapel mike and laid it on the laptop's speaker!

Anyway, thanks to everyone who was kind enough to come to my presentation. Sorry for the glitch. Try me again and I'll have it fixed.

Read More......

Sunday, March 2, 2008

Help wanted? (What's wrong with this picture? - XI)

The Canadian Medical Association is running a Help Wanted campaign to convince politicians and the public that Canada needs more doctors.

Here's the eye-catching ad that ran in the Globe and Mail yesterday:




Earlier in the week, I received a CMA mail-out containing a postcard. There was an exhortation to mail the postcard to the Prime Minister to draw his attention to Canada's physician shortage.

I didn't mail it.

Some times I ignore similar calls for political action purely out of apathy. This time, it's a stand on principle. I reject the premise that having more doctors will solve problems of access and quality in Canadian healthcare.

It may be part of the answer, but this campaign (see "alarming facts") ignores some broader issues.

"Do it yourself?" over the picture of a man suturing his own wound is a dramatic demonstration that some medical care should be provided by trained professionals (pace Rambo). But, is there an opportunity to educate patients to manage aspects of their care that currently "require" a physician? Why not DIY?

Most diabetics manage their own insulin to control their blood sugar. We trust patients to self-administer their prescription meds. What other "medical" duties can we educate our patients to perform? Can other personnel free up physicians to do the tasks that truly require their expertise?

The "More doctors. More care." slogan suggests that we're doing a great job already; we just need to more of it. There's remarkably little nuance to this argument.

What if we're not operating at maximum efficacy? If we crank up the number of practitioners, we'll multiply waste and poor quality.

Please note that I ask about operating at maximum efficacy , not efficiency. Many physicians are already putting in long hours and would find it difficult to work harder/more efficiently. But what are the outcomes of those long hours? Are we making a positive impact on chronic disease? How often do we really need to review the stable hypertensive's blood pressure? Or, in my practice, the man with an undetectable PSA after he's had surgery for prostate cancer?

Are we even asking ourselves these questions, or are we completely occupied with the struggle to keep our heads above the ceaseless demand for medical services?

Over the last year in my office, we've reevaluated many
of our practices/traditions/habits as part of our Advanced Access practice. Many of our procedures don't add value for our patients, and (by definition) are wasteful to the system. We're trying to change, but it's challenging, given the demands of a busy surgical practice. And (let's not ignore the 800 lb. gorilla in the room) the absence of fee-for-service remuneration for quality improvement efforts.

How much waste could be trimmed if the CMA put some of its "Help wanted" budget into quality improvement training, mentoring and support for physicians? How much physician time would this free up for additional patient care?

Dr. Day, show me some creativity beyond the sledgehammer approach of expanding the physician workforce.

Then, maybe I'll sign your postcard.




Read More......

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Start spreading the news - Advanced Access is working!

I'm catching up on work after a week off, so here's the lazy man's post - a link to last week's Advanced Access progress report.

Read More......

Friday, February 8, 2008

Advanced Access updates

I missed linking to the last few "Adventures in Advanced Access" posts. Here they are:

Not So Happy Holidays

Darwin's Cystoscope

Blog's Breakfast

Alberta Bound


Read More......

Monday, February 4, 2008

No-show no-no

I received this transcript from a CBC Radio Saskatchewan program:

CBC-RADIO, SASK. FEBRUARY 4, 2008. 6:30 HRS.

There could be warning signs at the doctor's office that say you have to pay a charge for missed appointments

PAT HUME [ANNOUNCER]
Don't be surprised if you see warning signs posted on the wall at your next appointment with a medical specialist. Those signs advise patients that if they miss or cancel appointments they could be billed. For skipped appointments the average is between $30 and $50 dollars. For missed procedures the cost is much higher.

Dr. Joe Pfeifer is President of the Saskatchewan Medical Association and a surgeon in Saskatoon. He says in his practice approximately one out of every ten patients misses or cancels appointments each day. Pfeifer says people also skip MRIs, CAT Scan and colonoscopies, procedures with huge waiting lists.

DR. JOE PFEIFER [President - Sask Medical Association]
Patients who do not show for appointments or procedures just create more of a burden on the system. It's a little disappointing that sometimes people have an attitude that is not the most responsible when it comes to health care because it is needy and there is such a shortage of resources and physicians. It's just sad to see them used badly.

PAT HUME [ANNOUNCER]
Under the Saskatchewan Medical Association's guide to uninsured services patients can be billed up to 50% of the cost of the missed appointment or procedure. Pfeifer says his office has seen fewer no-shows since a warning has appeared at the bottom of appointment cards.



Since we started our Advanced Access project last year, I've paid more attention to missed appointments or "no-shows". We've been tracking them regularly. In our practice, there's a 10-15% no-show rate. No-shows are different than cancelled appointments in that we at least get some warning about cancellations. Not so no-shows. They're completely wasted capacity. We don't know about them until after the appointment time has passed.

That's very frustrating for busy physicians who are trying to deal with long wait times. However, I'm disturbed by the tone of the CBC interview. It makes it sound like an adversarial process. Us vs. them. Only bad people miss appointments.

And they should pay a price!

What we have here is a treatment prescribed before a diagnosis is made.

Before laying blame, physicians need to look at the reasons for no-shows. Perhaps the letter announcing the appointment went astray. When that has happened at my office, the patient (or the referring physician) will call after a few weeks to ask when their appointment will be made. My staff will tell them that their appointment date has already passed, and we'll make a new appointment. Sometimes, under those circumstances, the patient will apologize for not attending the first appointment, even though it was our error in not notifying him!

Perhaps the problem is lack of transportation (Saskatchewan is a big place!), a sick child, or another unpredictable event. (Hard as it is to imagine, a doctor's appointment isn't always the most important event in a person's day!)

I'm interested in how no-show's relate to the length of wait between referral date and consultation date. When we started to work on reducing wait times in our office, patients were waiting up to 4 months for appointments. I have trouble remembering appointments 2 weeks from now (ask my wife), let alone 4 months!

Certainly, if you have a medical problem that's painful or debilitating, you'll remember that appointment with the doctor. But some "problems" (such as abnormal lab tests like high PSA levels, or traces of blood in the urine) don't cause symptoms. Pretty easy to forget when you're trying to get a crop off the field.

I wonder what charging for no-shows accomplishes. Perhaps it does reduce no-show rates, but what does it do for physicians' relationships with their patients? Given the relative lack of specialists in Saskatchewan, will some patients feel pressure to pay the fee, even if they had a valid reason for missing the appointment. And, if exceptions are allowed, who's going to judge their validity? I know I already have enough work to do without adding administrative work. I doubt that my office staff would be happy in this role, either.



Although it's certainly inadvertent, the message I get from the CBC piece is that the system is built to suit providers, not patients. Rather than blaming patients for missing appointments, let's try this: Ask what we could do differently to serve them better.

Could we:

Let patients choose their own appointment time?


Phone patients with a reminder 48 hours in advance?


Reduce our wait times?


By the way, doc, if you work on reducing your no-show rate, you'll also increase your revenues. (In a more satisfying way than by nickel-and-diming your patients with punitive fees.)

Physician, heal thyself.

Read More......

Saturday, January 12, 2008

What's wrong with this picture? - X

Today's WWWTP is a new post, Darwin's Cystoscope, at Adventures in Advanced Access.

Read More......

Friday, December 14, 2007

The Emperor's New Clothes

Doctors beware! There's a new sheriff in town and he wants his vasectomy done pronto.

New content on "Adventures in Improving Access".



Read More......

Thursday, December 6, 2007

Advanced Access in Qreview

HQC Qreview newsletter has an article about our Advanced Access project.

Read More......

Monday, November 12, 2007

Twice in a week!

Being in the national news, I mean. Not the other thing that is good twice a week.

Advanced Access in Saskatoon made the front page of the National Post last week. (Sorry if this link dies in the future.)

Read More......

Realpolitik

Just so you have the context of this post, I originally intended to post it on my HQC Advanced Access blog, following the recent Saskatchewan provincial election (which shut down any potentially politically inflammatory communication for the duration). However, perhaps it's a little too politically spicy for HQC, so here it is on PBW.



I'm back! Sorry to abandon you for a few weeks, but our provincial election rules prohibit propaganda. Any organization linked to the government (including health regions and this blog's sponsor, Health Quality Council) had to put the lid on anything that smelled political for the duration of the campaign. What do they think I could possibly say that could be considered subversive?


How about this: Advanced Access is the saviour of Canada's public health care system!


OK, it's no Communist Manifesto, but I sincerely believe it.


When proponents of privately-funded health care point out the failings of our system, long wait times are their major argument for creating a parallel delivery system. They assume that the present situation can't change; that it's inevitable to have these access problems.


But, how would a privately-funded system guarantee access to services? By using industrial methods of matching supply and demand, AKA Advanced Access! That's just good business.


You tricky M.B.A.'s! You know that managing supply and demand properly is the key to eliminating wait times. So why don't you put your resources into doing this in the public system rather than undermining it with a privately-funded one? Provide incentives for physicians and health regions to implement Advanced Access. Train project managers to implement the principles of clinical office redesign, and make their services available at no cost. (It's working for us... thanks, Karen and HQC!)

How much money would go into creating the infrastructure of a parallel, private system? I’ll bet if we took a fraction of that amount, we could significantly improve wait times through appropriate management. (Note: I’m not a professional economist and so am entitled to make blatantly unfounded claims like this.)


Ideological fights waste time, energy and resources. We can improve our current system. Lobby for Advanced Access in physicians’ offices, CT scanners and surgical wait lists. If you’re already involved in improvement projects like this, then spread the word. Encourage your co-workers to get involved.


If you support a parallel, private system, then you're a bad, bad person. But, you can probably be rehabilitated. Comrade.






Read More......