Well, almost. The ever-topical TV show, ER, featured surgical checklists in a recent episode. If that's what it takes to get the momentum going on implementation of checklists, I'm OK with that. Pressure and interest from the public will be a very powerful force to convince recalcitrant OR staff. (And, when I say recalcitrant OR staff, I think you know who I'm talking about.)
Thursday, March 19, 2009
Surgical checklists hit the big screen!
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:52 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Quality Improvement, Safety 0 comments
Sunday, March 1, 2009
Culture eats checklists for lunch
Last month, I made a day trip to Regina on a small, local airline. While I waited for my return flight in their Regina airport lounge, a Canadian Forces aircrew was also waiting. There were about a dozen of them, getting ready to fly out in their huge transport plane. The lounge was small, and the aircrew were quite boisterous, joking and clowning around. What happened next has been on my mind since then. But before I tell you about that...
Pre-op checklists garnered the limelight recently and briefly with the publication of the WHO international study that showed improvement in morbidity and mortality after the checklists were implemented. Just over a year ago, I blogged about WHO's checklist in beta version, and some responses I'd seen in the OR.
Not much has changed since then.
Recently, I was called into an OR room because the staff had difficulty inserting a catheter in a patient anaesthetized for abdominal surgery. I had to do another minor procedure to get the catheter in, and before starting, I asked if we should stop to do the preop checklist. The surgeon, who was waiting in the room, piped up dismissively, "Oh, jeez, come on. I know this guy!", and then proceeded to rattle off the patient's name, planned procedure, general health and allergies, auctioneer-style. "That checklist is such a waste of time", he concluded. There were sour looks on the staff's faces, but I couldn't tell whether it was because they agreed that the checklist was a waste of time, or because they disagreed with his assessment. The charge nurse went through the checklist, despite the surgeon's contempt.
Bryce Taylor, chair of Toronto's Department of Surgery and an author of the WHO report, was recently in Saskatoon to present the report, and discuss how to implement the checklist. One of the OR nurses who had attended the lecture commented that it might be difficult to convince all surgeons to embrace the checklist. I suggested that we needed to come up with the right incentives, perhaps going as far as linking the surgeon's access to OR time to his/her performance on critical patient safety issues. If our administration is truly committed to universal use of a safety checklist, they need to be anticipate that there may be a few surgeons who will push the issue that far.
The nurse laughed. "Can you please let me know when you're going to tell Dr. X that he can't operate until he does the checklist," she snorted. "I want to be in the room for that!"
These are a couple of examples of how the OR culture can affect improvement efforts. "Culture eats strategy for lunch" applies here.
But, don't despair! There are other cultures from which we can learn. Back to the airport...
The military aircrew were horsing around in the airport lounge when one of the officers quietly called out.
"Gentlemen. Let's get ready to fly."
Immediately, the aircrew settled down and gathered round. The officer recited the flight duration, altitude, weather conditions and other details. He called for questions. I suspect the crew members already knew most of the details of the flight, yet were completely attentive for the 1 minute briefing. The officer didn't need to raise his voice, or repeat his call for their attention.
Now, that is a professional, safety-conscious culture.
In my first OR vignette, the surgeon insisted that he already knew all the critical information about the patient and the planned surgery. Well, I certainly hope he would. But he misses the point that the checklist is not just for the surgeon; it's for the whole OR team. Also, the purpose of the checklist goes beyond the recitation of critical safety information. The checklist should foster and be part of a culture of open communication and cooperation in the OR. Check out some of the comments at the end of this Wall Street Journal article about the WHO checklist. People are amazed that checklists aren't already standard in ORs.
I guess it comes down to the Golden Rule. If you were on the OR table (or an airplane!), would you want the team looking after you to be communicating openly with the single goal of providing the safest, most effective service of which they were capable? Or are you comfortable with letting someone hinder, under the banner of professional autonomy, everyone else's efforts on your behalf?
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
2:56 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Safety 5 comments
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
The grass is always greener on the other side...
Check out US President (not yet, but he might as well be) Obama's video blog of his Economic Recovery Plan. He's going to make sure that all US hospitals and doctors' offices are outfitted with EMRs and are connected to each other (3:50 on the video).
EMR and connectivity are part of his core plan. "Cut red tape, prevent medical mistakes and help save billions of dollars each year..." Looks like his administration gets it.
Who would have thought the American health care system would be showing us the way on this?
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
11:41 p.m.
Labels: Electronic health records, Safety 0 comments
Sunday, August 3, 2008
Tom Peters takes on Health Care
Tom Peters (Re-Imagine) is just a little hot about Health Care. Check out his proposed hospital org chart.
He gets it.
Posted by
PBW
at
10:43 a.m.
Labels: Quality Improvement, Safety 0 comments
Thursday, May 29, 2008
Complications
As I started reading Atul Gawande's Complications: A Surgeon's Notes on an Imperfect Science, my first reaction was Nooooo! Don't give away the secrets!
When relating his first attempts at an invasive procedure (central venous catheter insertion), Gawande is so frank about his uncertainty and shortcomings, that it made me squirm to recall my own similar experiences.
All physicians gain experience through practice - on real, live patients. This practice, during residency, is supervised by senior attending physicians. However, as Gawande points out, the degree and proximity of supervision varies according to circumstance.
How do we balance being honest about our level of expertise against wanting to spare patients unnecessary anxiety? How can residents learn a new procedure if they don't perform it on a patient?
Gawande explores these questions with astonishing openness. Plus, he's a great storyteller. His story of the failed tracheostomy (lost airway, anyone?) made me cringe.
Non-physicians read this book at your own peril. You may dispel the myth of the infallible surgeon.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:04 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Quality Improvement, Safety 0 comments
Sunday, March 30, 2008
What's wrong with this picture? - XI (De-Sign)

This is a sharps container in the OR.
I definitely agree that we don't want to misplace pointy stuff with body fluids on them. But is this the best way to ensure safe disposal?
Here's a mobile computer monitor in the ER. It has 2 huge screens mounted at head height...
... and a tiny support stand that makes it necessary to...
... tape this handwritten note to the screen.
Who designs this stuff? Do they get any feedback from endusers? Would they be upset to see that the product they created has to be kludged with warning signs?
If you'll forgive me a little corny wordplay, doesn't the word "design" imply "de-sign", i.e. function is obvious and intuitive without ad hoc instructions? Even better, shouldn't the product somehow force us to use it safely and appropriately?
Recommended reading about design: Small Things Considered - Why there is no perfect design, by Henry Petroski.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
4:26 p.m.
Wednesday, January 9, 2008
Whoa to checklists?
Atul Gawande's at it again. Check out this NY Times op-ed about how bureaucracy shut down a successful program that reduced central line sepsis.
Excellent clinical care is no longer possible without doctors and nurses routinely using checklists and other organizational strategies and studying their results.
- Gawande
Read More......
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:26 p.m.
Labels: Quality Improvement, Safety 0 comments
Tuesday, January 8, 2008
Mmmm... Checklists!
More on the yummy goodness of checklists (c/o Atul Gawande).
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
9:59 a.m.
Labels: Quality Improvement, Safety 0 comments
Monday, December 24, 2007
He's making a list, checking it twice
Not Santa Claus... Your surgeon!
The World Health Organization is beta-testing a Surgical Safety Checklist as part of their "Safe Surgery Saves Lives" initiative. You can see the elements of the checklist here.
It's purpose is to improve communication between OR team members and avoid preventable errors during surgery.
Saskatoon Health Region's (SHR) already has a policy that a similar, somewhat shorter, checklist will be reviewed immediately before each procedure in the operating room. Our checklist is read out by the OR nurse and includes:Confirmation of the patient's name
Confirmation of the surgery planned (including which side of the body is to be operated on)
Review of any patient allergies
Asking the surgeon whether perioperative antibiotics are required
Make sense to do this? No-brainer, right? I'll bet if you've never worked in an operating room, you just presumed that some kind of "pre-flight check" was standard procedure.
Well, it is now, but it's only recently adopted. And not wholeheartedly accepted.
Surgeons are a very conservative bunch. And we tend not to like ideas that come from outside our community. Especially if the new ideas are perceived as being extra work for not much gain. SHR's preop checklist policy certainly fell into that category, at least initially. (I admit to being an early skeptic.)
Probably the best judges of how this policy is accepted by surgeons are OR nurses. In a completely arbitrary and invalid survey of OR nurses (read: gossip in the lounge), I found that surgeons' attitudes to the preop checklist varied widely. Some surgeons accept the policy and actively participate in the procedure. Many ignore the checklist as it's being read out. (One colleague commented to me that "it's a nursing procedure, not for surgeons.")
A few surgeons actively deride the checklists. I overheard a surgeon who mocked the nurse reading the checklist, saying "C'mon, I know you have to do this, but do you really think it makes any difference? Like I don't know what procedure I'm going to do on this patient?"
Well, doctor, check out the comments in these recent blog posts regarding wrong-side surgery and preop checklists in general:Suture for a living (The final paragraph says it all: Most important is for everyone involved to be engaged in the process...)
And, if you're still not convinced, watch Tom Shillue's standup comedy bit about wrong-side surgery.
More than Medicine (Think how much effort/anguish could have been saved by creating a system to prevent these mistakes.)
He makes it sound ridiculous. Because it is ridiculous.
Every member of the OR team should be actively involved in the preop checklist process. Maybe we should include one other person: the patient. I don't mean that the patient should listen and confirm the checklist in the OR - that would be impossible if they are sedated or asleep.
Instead, patients (families, caregivers, etc.) could be made aware that this is SHR's policy. They can be informed of this as part of their preop orientation. They may choose to confirm with their surgeon that he/she will make sure that the policy is followed during their surgery.
The surgeon may then choose one of these responses:Yes, certainly. I believe this is an important part of the system we have put in place to ensure your safety while you are in our care.
Now that should be a no-brainer.
What a load of crap! Do you really think that reading out some bureaucratic garbage is safer than my years of surgical experience? Either you trust me or you don't!
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
5:33 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Safety 0 comments
Thursday, September 13, 2007
Plays well with others (?)
Had an interesting conversation with an OR nurse earlier this week. She was upset about something that had happened in the theatre she was working in. (Not my theatre, but it easily could have been.) In addition to the planned major surgery, the patient unexpectedly required an additional minor procedure done that was within the general ability of the surgeon, but not within his area of expertise. When that additional procedure didn't seem to be going well (and eventually required calling in another surgeon), she was at a loss over how to suggest that the attempts be stopped and the other surgeon be called in sooner. There was some minor injury from the attempts, but that should heal without ill effect.
So, why couldn't she just speak up and voice her concern for the safety of the patient?
It's because the OR culture won out.
There is a definite hierarchy in health care generally, but it is very rigid in the operating room. From the top down: Doctor (surgeon slightly edges out anaesthetist), nurse, patient. Orders flow one direction. Suggestions coming up the other way are not always well-received. The nurse didn't feel safe in making a comment because she was afraid of being verbally abused in return.
Sometimes, the surgeon needs to overrule everyone else, based on his/her training, experience and ultimate responsibility for the patient's outcome. But there are many times where other OR staff's judgement and experience make them aware of risks to patient safety. If they are afraid to speak up, patients suffer harm. The silent staff will be upset and feel guilty that they didn't advocate on behalf of their patient.
Solutions?
Read More......Educate OR staff (?role-playing, ?simulations) how to tactfully (yet firmly) express a safety concern to the surgeon
Convince surgeons that their patients may have a better outcome if everyone on the OR team is welcomed as an active participant in patient safety and quality improvement initiatives
Let all the crotchety old surgeons retire and train the new ones to play well with others
Any suggestions?
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
12:27 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Safety 0 comments