Hi! Long time, no see.
Thanks to Mark Wahba's keen eye for this one:
Bright yellow "Sharps" containers are ubiquitous in health care facilities. Pointy, pokey stuff goes in them after it's been used. This reduces the chance of needle-stick injuries. While the containers come in different shapes and sizes, their uniform yellow color is a strong visual cue as to their presence and purpose.
However, someone tried to "re-purpose" this large sharps container for something else. They had relabeled the contained, but that label didn't last long. Even if it were now being used for regular garbage, it's still unsafe because the staff emptying the garbage wouldn't be expecting uncovered needles in the container.
Surely, you say, a person would stop and think before dropping sharps into this container. After all, there are clues that it isn't a real sharps container: it's sitting on the floor, there's no safety top to prevent people's hands from rooting around inside.
You'd be wrong. Mark mentioned that he had dropped one sharp into it already. And why wouldn't he... the containers give a (supposedly) unique visual cue.
The best part of this story is that Mark pointed (sorry...) out the problem to the department manager, and the practice was stopped!
Here's another example of someone messing with visual cues:
Clean isolation gowns used to be folded and stacked on carts outside a patient's room. You would put one on, enter the room to perform care, and then discard the dirty gown into a laundry hamper outside the room.
Then, someone had the idea of leaving the gowns unfolded, in large plastic linen bags. I'm sure that saves a lot of time by cutting out the folding process. Unfortunately, the "clean" plastic linen bag with rumpled gowns in the bottom of it just screams "Put your dirty laundry in here!" Once a dirty gown has been dropped in, the entire bag is contaminated, and has to be laundered again. Or, worse, the wayward gown is not recognized and then is a source for cross-contamination for another patient.
I've made the mistake myself.
Someone has recognized that it's a problem and tried to remedy it with a hand-lettered sign on the bag. Nice try, but the sign presumes that the person about to dump their dirty gown into the bag is approaching it from the side the sign is on. Also, it presumes that they can read English.
We get clear and important information from standardized visual cues: Skull and crossbones on a plastic bottle - Poison!, Red light - Stop! They prompt us to act, or prevent us from harmful action, in critical situations, without the need for deliberation. Don't ignore people's mental inertia when redesigning the system.
Monday, August 31, 2009
What's wrong with this picture? - XV Don't mess with success!
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
2:58 p.m.
Labels: Communication, What's wrong with this picture? 1 comments
Sunday, March 8, 2009
What's wrong with this picture? - XIII

Last week, I noticed someone had nailed a green doodad onto the door of each operating room.
Any guesses what it's for?
I suppose this is a trick question "What's wrong with this picture?" because this is really an example of great design. WWWTP is usually about bad design, but I'm going to broaden things a bit to allow for this doodad.
It's a room marker in case we have to evacuate the OR because of a fire or other disaster. The fire marshall checks each room to make sure it's empty, then closes the door and flips the doodad up so it rests on the door frame in an upright position:
If anyone opens the door again, the doodad swings back down to its original position, indicating that the room may have been reentered.
Simple. Brilliant. Sweet.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:56 p.m.
Wednesday, June 4, 2008
Welcome to Strategy readers!
Plain Brown Wrapper is mentioned in this quarter's Strategy, the CMA's financial management magazine. If the Strategy article led you here, thanks for coming. Have a look around the site. I have the most fun with "What's wrong with this picture".
Also, I'm very excited about our office's ongoing Advanced Access project (latest post here), chronicled at Health Quality Council's website. We're trying to reduce patient wait times in our 9-physician urology group.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:06 a.m.
Labels: Advanced Access project, Communication, What's wrong with this picture? 0 comments
Sunday, June 1, 2008
What's wrong with this picture? VII - Reloaded
Remember this post about patient confidentiality on a hospital ward?
Well, they fixed the problem!
And so simply and elegantly, too. They just turned the req over before clipping it up. Sure, anyone can still take a look at the req, but they have to make an active effort to do so.
Well done!
I also learned something from this experience. When I had originally noticed this problem, I brought it to the attention of the ward clerk. The response was essentially: "That's the way we do it here, and I don't see a problem with it." That's often the response I get when I point out some of the situations that I gripe about in What's wrong with this picture?
Maybe it's because I don't present the problem in a compelling way. Or maybe there just isn't a strong culture of patient-centredness out there yet. Or maybe I'm telling the wrong people.
Choice number three seemed to be the problem this time. The nurse manager actually found the problem through this blog and then fixed it. She wished that I had brought the problem directly to her attention. She was right.
So, in future, if I'm serious about getting something fixed (rather than just generating material to post here), I'll talk to the person who has the authority to make the changes.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
6:01 p.m.
Tuesday, April 15, 2008
What's wrong with this picture? - XII


Chef?!
Oh, yeah... The new Buffalo Chicken Bite with Ranch dressing!
C'est magnifique!
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
8:44 p.m.
Sunday, March 30, 2008
What's wrong with this picture? - XI (De-Sign)

This is a sharps container in the OR.
I definitely agree that we don't want to misplace pointy stuff with body fluids on them. But is this the best way to ensure safe disposal?
Here's a mobile computer monitor in the ER. It has 2 huge screens mounted at head height...
... and a tiny support stand that makes it necessary to...
... tape this handwritten note to the screen.
Who designs this stuff? Do they get any feedback from endusers? Would they be upset to see that the product they created has to be kludged with warning signs?
If you'll forgive me a little corny wordplay, doesn't the word "design" imply "de-sign", i.e. function is obvious and intuitive without ad hoc instructions? Even better, shouldn't the product somehow force us to use it safely and appropriately?
Recommended reading about design: Small Things Considered - Why there is no perfect design, by Henry Petroski.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
4:26 p.m.
Sunday, March 2, 2008
Help wanted? (What's wrong with this picture? - XI)
The Canadian Medical Association is running a Help Wanted campaign to convince politicians and the public that Canada needs more doctors.
Here's the eye-catching ad that ran in the Globe and Mail yesterday:
Earlier in the week, I received a CMA mail-out containing a postcard. There was an exhortation to mail the postcard to the Prime Minister to draw his attention to Canada's physician shortage.
I didn't mail it.
Some times I ignore similar calls for political action purely out of apathy. This time, it's a stand on principle. I reject the premise that having more doctors will solve problems of access and quality in Canadian healthcare.
It may be part of the answer, but this campaign (see "alarming facts") ignores some broader issues.
"Do it yourself?" over the picture of a man suturing his own wound is a dramatic demonstration that some medical care should be provided by trained professionals (pace Rambo). But, is there an opportunity to educate patients to manage aspects of their care that currently "require" a physician? Why not DIY?
Most diabetics manage their own insulin to control their blood sugar. We trust patients to self-administer their prescription meds. What other "medical" duties can we educate our patients to perform? Can other personnel free up physicians to do the tasks that truly require their expertise?
The "More doctors. More care." slogan suggests that we're doing a great job already; we just need to more of it. There's remarkably little nuance to this argument.
What if we're not operating at maximum efficacy? If we crank up the number of practitioners, we'll multiply waste and poor quality.
Please note that I ask about operating at maximum efficacy , not efficiency. Many physicians are already putting in long hours and would find it difficult to work harder/more efficiently. But what are the outcomes of those long hours? Are we making a positive impact on chronic disease? How often do we really need to review the stable hypertensive's blood pressure? Or, in my practice, the man with an undetectable PSA after he's had surgery for prostate cancer?
Are we even asking ourselves these questions, or are we completely occupied with the struggle to keep our heads above the ceaseless demand for medical services?
Over the last year in my office, we've reevaluated many of our practices/traditions/habits as part of our Advanced Access practice. Many of our procedures don't add value for our patients, and (by definition) are wasteful to the system. We're trying to change, but it's challenging, given the demands of a busy surgical practice. And (let's not ignore the 800 lb. gorilla in the room) the absence of fee-for-service remuneration for quality improvement efforts.
How much waste could be trimmed if the CMA put some of its "Help wanted" budget into quality improvement training, mentoring and support for physicians? How much physician time would this free up for additional patient care?
Dr. Day, show me some creativity beyond the sledgehammer approach of expanding the physician workforce.
Then, maybe I'll sign your postcard.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
5:18 p.m.
Labels: Advanced Access project, Quality Improvement, What's wrong with this picture? 2 comments
Friday, February 8, 2008
What's wrong with this picture? - X (Med school, Old school)


This lab coat, belonging to a senior medical student, was hanging in the lounge last week. The pockets were stuffed to bursting. In addition to 6 (!!!) reference books (Surgery on call, Internal Medicine on call, etc.), there was a set of critical care flashcards. Geez, buddy, are you part pack mule?
How about trading your collapsed vertebrae in for a PDA? Get some electronic references installed and whip it out when you see your next patient with Dengue fever.
Better yet, convince the College of Medicine to provide access to a standard set of digital reference books (reviewed and approved by faculty) to all medical students. You could use them through any internet connection (ideally wireless via PDA) and they would be updated more regularly than print references.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
9:53 a.m.
Labels: Communication, Electronic health records, What's wrong with this picture? 0 comments
Saturday, January 12, 2008
What's wrong with this picture? - X
Today's WWWTP is a new post, Darwin's Cystoscope, at Adventures in Advanced Access.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
3:41 p.m.
Labels: Advanced Access project, Quality Improvement, What's wrong with this picture? 0 comments
Thursday, December 13, 2007
What's wrong with this picture? - IX

Here are the mail slots in our doctor's lounge.
Last week, each one was stuffed with this memo. Don't get me wrong here - there's nothing wrong with the memo. It's useful info. But, once I've read it...

There are about 100 mail slots in the lounge. All of them get the memo, even the ones for doctors who have retired or moved. (Why do we still have those slots?) The garbage can fills up pretty quickly on memo day.
The holidays are particularly hard on the forests. Today was a 3-memo day.


Earlier this year (I believe it was during the Easter paper blizzard), I called the admin assistant responsible for these memos and asked if the information could be sent out by email. Just set up an email group and press 'Send'.
Think of the savings: Paper, ink, delivery time, less garbage to haul.
Well, it's Christmas and the memos keep coming.
Happy Holidays, Office Depot!
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
9:41 p.m.
Tuesday, December 11, 2007
What's wrong with this picture? - VIII (extended dance mix)

Where do you think this is from?
A. Victoria's Secret?
B. www.carwashmommas.com?
C. The "Squeegee kids we'd like to meet" feature in Maxim magazine?
Answer: None of the above. This is from...
... the Canadian Medical Association Journal!
No lie. Here's the whole ad from the October 9 issue.
Testim is a testosterone gel marketed to men with low testosterone levels. You get the gist of the ad: If you didn't answer the ad's quiz with "C", maybe you need to smear a little Testim on your hypogonadal self.
This is not the type of ad you usually see in a medical journal (note that, in the actual journal, the ad is in full, glossy color and much more, uh, life-like). No doubt an attention-seeking ploy by the marketers.
And, attention they got.
Check out these letters in the December 4 CMAJ (under the title "Advertisement". You need to open each PDF. Sorry, that's the way CMAJ is set up).
Some readers were upset that this ad, demeaning to women, they say, appeared in a medical journal (or anywhere, if I understand some of the letters). I agree with their point and that this isn't appropriate for the CMAJ, despite the protestations from Paladin Labs.
But, would it be disingenuous to suggest that the ad is also demeaning to men? The message to men is that, if you don't dissolve into a drooling, hormone-fueled, horn-honking mess when this woman appears in your car windshield, then there must be something wrong with you.
And you should be medicated.
Anyway, I particularly like the response from Paladin's VP, Sales and Marketing, Mark Beaudet, who stays on message and insists that everything is on the up and up.
"We did physician focus groups, for goodness sake!" (I'm paraphrasing.) Where? At a stag party?
Well, M. VP, you're the Marketing professional. We'll just have to see how this ad plays out for the rest of the campaign. You are sticking to your guns and carrying on with the campaign, aren't you?
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:31 p.m.
Monday, December 10, 2007
What's wrong with this picture? - VII

The yellow sheet clipped to a notice board is an X-ray requisition.
Anyone see a problem with that?
While on rounds this morning, I noticed that this ward has the practice of posting their X-ray reqs like this. I presume it's so they're easy to get at when a porter comes to transport the patient to the X-ray department. Whatever the reason may be, I suggest they rethink this practice.
Anyone walking by can read what's on the req, including the patient's name and details of their medical condition. Would you want your private information displayed like this?
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
8:52 p.m.
Friday, December 7, 2007
What's wrong with this picture? - VI part II
O.K. Maybe I'm going overboard with this drippy-hands thing, but here it is again.
This cutlery has been washed and laid out to dry right underneath the paper-towel dispenser! I know I dripped all over them when I grabbed some towel.
This is in the kitchen of the OR lounge. Yes, the Operating Room, where they're supposed to know a little something about contamination, proper handling technique, etc. Sheesh!
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
8:57 p.m.
Thursday, December 6, 2007
What's wrong with this picture? - VI

Can you spot it?
Well, yuck. Someone's left their drinks under the paper towel dispenser!
Which is fine if you don't mind someone dripping soapy water, hair and general effluvia into your cola. I know I'm trying to cut down on effluvia.
On the ward, I notice that boxes of exam gloves are often left next to the sink, under the towel dispenser. Nothing says "I love you" better than a box of dripping wet plastic gloves.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:39 p.m.
Thursday, November 29, 2007
What's wrong with this picture? - V

Inside the men's washroom next to our office
Missed the garbage can... again!
I wondered what was going on when, regularly over the last few months, there were crumpled paper towels on the floor just inside the washroom door. But I think I've figured it out.
To keep their hands clean, guys are using the towels to turn the door handle. Because there's no garbage can beside the door... on the floor they go.
Bathroom architects take note: put a garbage can beside (or within 3-point range of) bathroom doors. Better yet, no bathroom doors, a la airport washrooms where you walk through an angled entrance that gives visual privacy.
I wonder what these hygiene-freaks do when the washroom has a hot-air hand "dryer" and no towels. Wait for the next guy to come along and open the door, I guess.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
11:31 p.m.
Friday, November 16, 2007
What's wrong with this picture? - IV

Operating room scrub sink
Soapy water makes stuff slippery?! If you're getting the hang of "What's wrong with this picture?", you know where I'm going with this.
Don't try to change behavior with signs; change the system! How about some non-slip mats on the floor in front of the sinks? What about getting rid of soap and water altogether? Use antiseptic lotions instead.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
9:47 p.m.
Friday, November 9, 2007
What's wrong with this picture? - III


Doctor's parking lot - Nov. 8 12:10 pm
Doctor's parking lot - Nov. 8 15:23 pm
Different car
To be fair, even though there was no visible handicapped sticker on either car, it's possible that the drivers were handicapped in some way. I mean, other than morally.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
11:34 p.m.
Sunday, October 28, 2007
What's wrong with this picture? - II

Here's a close-up:
This is photo from the OR change room, but I've seen the same sign in many places around the hospital. I understand the problem: Laundry bag too full = heavy weight = back injury. But is this sign the best solution?
Rather than relying on people not to overfill the bags, we need to change the system so they can't overfill the bags. How about using smaller bags? Of course, the bags will need to be changed more often, or more bags need to be in place so laundry doesn't overflow onto the floor.
See the previous "What's wrong with this picture?". There's a pattern here. I'll keep an eye out for other examples and report back to you.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:56 a.m.
Labels: Communication, Quality Improvement, What's wrong with this picture? 1 comments
Monday, October 22, 2007
What's wrong with this picture?

Here's a close-up:
This is a door at one of our local health facilities. By the presence of the fancy electronic lock, you might imagine that there's a reason to keep unauthorized personnel out. Alas, the door doesn't reliable close on its own, so we're relying on people to remember to pull the door closed manually. 
Here's the other side of the door. No sign! So if you're on the way out, you won't be reminded.
Shouldn't the sign on this door read: Attention: Maintenance! Please fix this door. (?)
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
8:46 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Quality Improvement, What's wrong with this picture? 0 comments