Showing posts with label Communication. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Communication. Show all posts

Monday, August 31, 2009

What's wrong with this picture? - XV Don't mess with success!

Hi! Long time, no see.

Thanks to Mark Wahba's keen eye for this one:




Bright yellow "Sharps" containers are ubiquitous in health care facilities. Pointy, pokey stuff goes in them after it's been used. This reduces the chance of needle-stick injuries. While the containers come in different shapes and sizes, their uniform yellow color is a strong visual cue as to their presence and purpose.

However, someone tried to "re-purpose" this large sharps container for something else. They had relabeled the contained, but that label didn't last long. Even if it were now being used for regular garbage, it's still unsafe because the staff emptying the garbage wouldn't be expecting uncovered needles in the container.

Surely, you say, a person would stop and think before dropping sharps into this container. After all, there are clues that it isn't a real sharps container: it's sitting on the floor, there's no safety top to prevent people's hands from rooting around inside.

You'd be wrong. Mark mentioned that he had dropped one sharp into it already. And why wouldn't he... the containers give a (supposedly) unique visual cue.

The best part of this story is that Mark pointed (sorry...) out the problem to the department manager, and the practice was stopped!

Here's another example of someone messing with visual cues:



Clean isolation gowns used to be folded and stacked on carts outside a patient's room. You would put one on, enter the room to perform care, and then discard the dirty gown into a laundry hamper outside the room.

Then, someone had the idea of leaving the gowns unfolded, in large plastic linen bags. I'm sure that saves a lot of time by cutting out the folding process. Unfortunately, the "clean" plastic linen bag with rumpled gowns in the bottom of it just screams "Put your dirty laundry in here!" Once a dirty gown has been dropped in, the entire bag is contaminated, and has to be laundered again. Or, worse, the wayward gown is not recognized and then is a source for cross-contamination for another patient.

I've made the mistake myself.

Someone has recognized that it's a problem and tried to remedy it with a hand-lettered sign on the bag. Nice try, but the sign presumes that the person about to dump their dirty gown into the bag is approaching it from the side the sign is on. Also, it presumes that they can read English.

We get clear and important information from standardized visual cues: Skull and crossbones on a plastic bottle - Poison!, Red light - Stop! They prompt us to act, or prevent us from harmful action, in critical situations, without the need for deliberation. Don't ignore people's mental inertia when redesigning the system.

Read More......

Thursday, March 19, 2009

Surgical checklists hit the big screen!

Well, almost. The ever-topical TV show, ER, featured surgical checklists in a recent episode. If that's what it takes to get the momentum going on implementation of checklists, I'm OK with that. Pressure and interest from the public will be a very powerful force to convince recalcitrant OR staff. (And, when I say recalcitrant OR staff, I think you know who I'm talking about.)

Read More......

Sunday, March 1, 2009

'Difficult' patients

Want to know what patient-centred/patient-directed care could look like? Read "On being a 'Difficult' Patient" by Michelle Mayer.

Then, if you have some time, and a box of Kleenex, go to her blog "Portrait of a Dying Mom".

Read More......

Culture eats checklists for lunch

Last month, I made a day trip to Regina on a small, local airline. While I waited for my return flight in their Regina airport lounge, a Canadian Forces aircrew was also waiting. There were about a dozen of them, getting ready to fly out in their huge transport plane. The lounge was small, and the aircrew were quite boisterous, joking and clowning around. What happened next has been on my mind since then. But before I tell you about that...


Pre-op checklists garnered the limelight recently and briefly with the publication of the WHO international study that showed improvement in morbidity and mortality after the checklists were implemented. Just over a year ago, I blogged about WHO's checklist in beta version, and some responses I'd seen in the OR.

Not much has changed since then.

Recently, I was called into an OR room because the staff had difficulty inserting a catheter in a patient anaesthetized for abdominal surgery. I had to do another minor procedure to get the catheter in, and before starting, I asked if we should stop to do the preop checklist. The surgeon, who was waiting in the room, piped up dismissively, "Oh, jeez, come on. I know this guy!", and then proceeded to rattle off the patient's name, planned procedure, general health and allergies, auctioneer-style. "That checklist is such a waste of time", he concluded. There were sour looks on the staff's faces, but I couldn't tell whether it was because they agreed that the checklist was a waste of time, or because they disagreed with his assessment. The charge nurse went through the checklist, despite the surgeon's contempt.

Bryce Taylor, chair of Toronto's Department of Surgery and an author of the WHO report, was recently in Saskatoon to present the report, and discuss how to implement the checklist. One of the OR nurses who had attended the lecture commented that it might be difficult to convince all surgeons to embrace the checklist. I suggested that we needed to come up with the right incentives, perhaps going as far as linking the surgeon's access to OR time to his/her performance on critical patient safety issues. If our administration is truly committed to universal use of a safety checklist, they need to be anticipate that there may be a few surgeons who will push the issue that far.

The nurse laughed. "Can you please let me know when you're going to tell Dr. X that he can't operate until he does the checklist," she snorted. "I want to be in the room for that!"

These are a couple of examples of how the OR culture can affect improvement efforts. "Culture eats strategy for lunch" applies here.

But, don't despair! There are other cultures from which we can learn. Back to the airport...

The military aircrew were horsing around in the airport lounge when one of the officers quietly called out.

"Gentlemen. Let's get ready to fly."

Immediately, the aircrew settled down and gathered round. The officer recited the flight duration, altitude, weather conditions and other details. He called for questions. I suspect the crew members already knew most of the details of the flight, yet were completely attentive for the 1 minute briefing. The officer didn't need to raise his voice, or repeat his call for their attention.

Now, that is a professional, safety-conscious culture.

In my first OR vignette, the surgeon insisted that he already knew all the critical information about the patient and the planned surgery. Well, I certainly hope he would. But he misses the point that the checklist is not just for the surgeon; it's for the whole OR team. Also, the purpose of the checklist goes beyond the recitation of critical safety information. The checklist should foster and be part of a culture of open communication and cooperation in the OR. Check out some of the comments at the end of this Wall Street Journal article about the WHO checklist. People are amazed that checklists aren't already standard in ORs.

I guess it comes down to the Golden Rule. If you were on the OR table (or an airplane!), would you want the team looking after you to be communicating openly with the single goal of providing the safest, most effective service of which they were capable? Or are you comfortable with letting someone hinder, under the banner of professional autonomy, everyone else's efforts on your behalf?

Read More......

Sunday, November 30, 2008

Review of Doctor review sites missing an opportunity

Dr. Kent Sepkowitz informs Slate readers that doctor review sites aren't helpful for patients. But can they be helpful for doctors? I think so - check out this old post.

Read More......

Thursday, September 25, 2008

Wonder words

Long time, no blog. No excuses, just life.


I was reviewing a patient's chart this morning, and several phrases in nursing/physician notes caught my attention: Patient refused breakfast. Patient denies shortness of breath.

If you're a hospital caregiver, you've seen similar stuff written on charts. Wording notes this way makes it sound like patients are our adversaries. Like we're suspicious of what they say and do. Like the little sneaks can't be trusted. (Oh, he denied shortness of breath, but I think we know better. Refused breakfast, did he? Well, we'll just see about that!)

I've also seen people refer to themselves in progress notes as "The writer" rather than saying "I", as in "The writer observed the patient performing self-care", instead of "I watched Mr. Jones perform self-care." What's the reason for that? Is "the writer" somehow more professional and credible? I also wonder why people write "Patient stated" or "Patient verbalized" rather than "Patient said".

And, if you're a patient, don't ever dare to leave the hospital "Against Medical Advice". If that gets written on your chart, you're branded as an uncooperative jerk.

Which you may be.

But, you may also have needed to deal with an urgent personal matter, and your doctor didn't see fit to make ward rounds and write your discharge order at a reasonable time. "Uncooperative jerk" cuts both ways. " Discharged self AMA" sounds like we're running prisons rather than hospitals.





Read More......

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

Warts and all

Dan Walter put a comment on my last post, and it's left me a bit of a dilemma.

He comments that he's "off topic", and, after I did a little homework/surfing, I think he's right. In fact, his post is essentially spam to promote his website/agenda.

And an angry agenda it is!

Dan has left a link to Adventures in Cardiology which is a bitter-voiced (and perhaps rightly so...) personal account of medical misadventures (yes, that's a euphemism!).

So, what should I do with his comment, which had nothing to do with my post about Powerpoint presentations? My first thought was to just delete the comment and have done with it. Obviously, he wants to draw a wide audience to his website to hear his story. How much of the story is accurate? The tone he takes is aggressively negative ("mangled", "ripped to shreds", "bumbling cardiology staff", "Warfarin is commonly used as rat poison") and, frankly, off-putting.

My immediate, visceral impression was to write him off as a crank. He comes across as an angry man who's more interested in trashing, rather than improving, the system.

But, maybe there's some lessons to be learned here (curse you, cooler, contemplative side of my brain!). If medical staff truly made the mistakes Dan chronicles, then the next steps post-error were most critical in moving on: honesty, communication and transparency. Our provincial licensing body repeated tells us that most complaints lodged against physicians are on the basis of poor communication, whether or not there was any medical misadventure. From Dan's story, it sounds like this was a big part of the problem, compounding the actual medical complications.

Even if the medical team weren't "responsible" for any of the misfortune Dan has described, the system has nonetheless failed him and his family. After all, if we want to consider that we practice "Patient/Client and Family-Centred Care" (PFCC), then it is our patients/clients who get to decide whether or not they are satisfied with the results.

Their satisfaction will be based primarily not on the outcome measures favored by the healthcare system (mortality, infection rates, length of stay), but on their experience in the system. Were they treated with respect and dignity? Were they invited to participate in decision-making to the level they wished? Was all pertinent information shared promptly, freely and in a format that the patient and family could understand and use in collaborative decision-making?

And so, Dan's link remains on my blog. If you do check out his site , try this experiment: Read it first from the point of view of a health professional dealing with this "difficult and demanding" family member. Think about how you would cringe, and look for an escape-route, if you saw Dan coming down the hallway of your hospital ward. What a jerk this guy is! He just doesn't understand the complexity of problems we're dealing with every day.

(As I noted above, this circle-the-wagons approach was my first instinct.)

Then try looking through a "customer-service" lens: I want to provide each client with an excellent experience that will reflect well on me personally, my profession and my institution. How can I change the system (yes, I can!) to serve Dan and his family better?

BTW, it's an open-book quiz - the answers are all here.

Read More......

Monday, June 9, 2008

Stop talking over patients!

Today, at the hospital, I saw a porter pushing a patient in a wheelchair. She stopped to talk to an acquaintance as they passed in the hallway. Their conversation was loud and of a personal nature.

As they talked, the man in the wheelchair fidgeted, obviously uncomfortable with being ignored. It made me think of a recent article "Talking over patients: sTOP" in CMAJ's Salon.

sTOP is a different take on the "loose lips" problem in hospitals (and healthcare, in general).

Ken Flegel goes beyond pointing out how rude it is to subject patients to our personal conversations, and tells us it's unethical.

"TOP Talk is an unprofessional behaviour not because the topic of conversation is bad, but because the circumstance is an unacceptable time and place for it."


Even if you think that's a little over the top (I don't!), you have to admit that "TOP talk" happens regularly in healthcare settings.

I mentioned the porters in my example, but physicians and nurses are as guilty of this. I don't think Flegel is telling us that we can't have personal conversations at work, but when with our patients, to treat them as special guests.

Like we would want to be treated, if in their shoes.

Or wheelchair.

Read More......

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

Welcome to Strategy readers!

Plain Brown Wrapper is mentioned in this quarter's Strategy, the CMA's financial management magazine. If the Strategy article led you here, thanks for coming. Have a look around the site. I have the most fun with "What's wrong with this picture".

Also, I'm very excited about our office's ongoing Advanced Access project (latest post here), chronicled at Health Quality Council's website. We're trying to reduce patient wait times in our 9-physician urology group.

Read More......

Thursday, May 29, 2008

Complications

As I started reading Atul Gawande's Complications: A Surgeon's Notes on an Imperfect Science, my first reaction was Nooooo! Don't give away the secrets!

When relating his first attempts at an invasive procedure (central venous catheter insertion), Gawande is so frank about his uncertainty and shortcomings, that it made me squirm to recall my own similar experiences.

All physicians gain experience through practice - on real, live patients. This practice, during residency, is supervised by senior attending physicians. However, as Gawande points out, the degree and proximity of supervision varies according to circumstance.

How do we balance being honest about our level of expertise against wanting to spare patients unnecessary anxiety? How can residents learn a new procedure if they don't perform it on a patient?

Gawande explores these questions with astonishing openness. Plus, he's a great storyteller. His story of the failed tracheostomy (lost airway, anyone?) made me cringe.

Non-physicians read this book at your own peril. You may dispel the myth of the infallible surgeon.

Read More......

Thursday, May 15, 2008

RateMDs lawsuit

An Edmonton urologist has slapped RateMDs with a $12M lawsuit. Apparently he was upset about the "bad publicity" from his RateMDs page.

Talk about counterproductive. Now he's got that "bad publicity" all over the papers.

Read More......

Sunday, May 4, 2008

I blog, therefore I am

"Friends tell me that I will take naturally to blogging because I am in possession of many poorly considered opinions about issues I understand only marginally."

A wry take on blogging, at The Atlantic.

Read More......

Crash and Learn II

Some more ideas from Crash and Learn by Jim Smith Jr.

Chapter 2 - Room Setup Mistakes

My first inclination was to skip this chapter. After all, in most cases, I don't have much say in how a room is set up.

Or maybe it doesn't matter to me how the room is setup, as long as everyone is facing the front and can see me.

Or maybe I'm not aware of the recent breakthroughs (there must be some!) in room-setup theory that optimize audience experience.

It's a brief chapter, but Smith has a couple of suggestions that would be a departure from the traditional medical lecture setting:

Have a brief, content-related activity waiting for the participants when they enter the room

Play music (!)


My three top mistakes are:

1. Not having an activity to engage my audience as soon as they enter the room

2. Not playing music (!)

3. Letting the room get too hot

My action steps to correct these mistakes are:

1. Create a "Welcome" slideshow. Maybe something like the clips that play in movie theatres before the previews start - trivia questions, short cartoons, etc.

2. Play music (Need those portable speakers!)

3. Check out the thermostat before starting. Asking someone in the room to be in charge of opening a door or window if it does become too hot.

I'm committed to correcting these mistakes because:

1. Having the audience focused on an activity will make it easier to get their attention when I want to start speaking.

2. Music might be a way to get the audience's energy up if the presentation is late in the day.

3. Audiences can't concentrate if they are physically uncomfortable. They will be thinking about their discomfort rather than the message of my talk.



Read More......

Sunday, April 20, 2008

Crash and Learn I

I'm still fussed about the presentation I gave at SAHO earlier this week. I've been making notes on what to improve for next time, and I have a strong feeling that I could be doing a lot more with my presentations.

I think I can apply some of the ideas about transparency from today's earlier post to improving my presentations. That is, I'm going to make a commitment to improve, and record my efforts here.

Yesterday, I picked up Crash and Learn - 600+ Road-tested tips to keep audiences fired up and engaged! by Jim Smith Jr. He's described as "a sought-after motivational speaker". It's just over 100 pages and I liked the practical, bullet-point tips and "war story" format.

As is the case for most physicians, I haven't received formal training on how to speak in public, give presentations, or teach a class. Yet, I'm called on regularly to do all these things. I just follow the "traditional" approaches to lectures and Grand Round presentations, i.e. stand at the front (behind a podium) and talk. Non-stop. For the full hour, if not longer.

We've set the bar so low in most "medical" presentations, that it's a rare treat to see a speaker who brings something (anything!) fresh and exciting to their presentation.

Let's see what Sought-After Motivational Speaker Jim Smith Jr. has to offer.

Chapter 1 - Facilitation Mistakes

In this chapter, "Jim's Gems" seem more applicable to facilitators leading interactive sessions than to the lecture format taken in most medical settings. Nice tips on how to involve your audience, get people back from breaks on time, and deal with distractions.

Hmm... Maybe "lectures" should be made more interactive in order to engage audiences. Why don't we do that routinely? Perhaps because we don't have the training, experience and confidence to do it. Plus, if I involve the audience, I might lose control of the session.

Smith emphasizes the need to open the session in a strong, memorable way. Use a story, powerful quote, "get-up-out-of-your-seat" activity, or a surprising, powerful statistic. He has similar suggestions for a strong closing.

I was surprised to read that he avoids closing with questions and answers, suggesting "The wrong question can sour the atmosphere, leaving a bitter closing taste. Moreover, you might run out of time without thoroughly answering the question." So, I guess you need to have a prepared closing that gives a reliable, strong, positive finish to your presentation, and plan to deliver the closing after the questions and answers.

Take-away quote: "View your participants as the most important people in the room. Put your ego in check."

Now, I hate the self-help books that have "reader participation", i.e. write down your action plan at the end of each chapter. But, as I'm committing to doing this publicly, here we go:

My top three mistakes are:

1. Not opening sessions in a strong, memorable way

2. Going off on tangents when answering questions

3. Too much telling, not enough asking during the session

My action steps to correct these mistakes are:

1. Open with a related story

2. Ask for the question to be repeated or restated, or paraphrase the question back to the questioner, so I can focus my answer

3. Structure presentations with points where audience can make suggestions. Or solicit questions during the presentation

I'm committed to correcting these mistakes because:

I want my audience to be engaged in the presentation, keep their energy up, and answer questions to their satisfaction.


I've got a presentation to give tomorrow, so I'll try to come up with a relevant story that I can open and close with.




Read More......

Blogging to a better you

This Globe and Mail article struck a chord with me. While I haven't been blogging about the intimate topics (personal financial disasters, obesity/weight loss) discussed, I have had some of the same thoughts expressed by the bloggers interviewed.

The article's theme is: Making your personal goals public will boost your resolve.

A small example in Plain Brown Wrapper was my New Year's resolution to wear my name tag at work. I'm sure no one at the hospital reads PBW, but the possibility that someone might catch me without my tag and comment "Didn't I read your blog..." was a motivator. I've been pretty consistent in wearing it.

My Advanced Access blog has put our project into the public eye. We get about 700 hits every 2 weeks. Just knowing that so many people are following our progress keeps me focussed and excited about the project.

I agreed with many quotes in the G&M article, like "... she receives some of the best feedback from readers when she posts entries that make her feel vulnerable." and "... blogging is not for the faint of heart."

But, I take issue with "Openly failing, however, is a blog risk... many bloggers opt for anonymity." Certainly, some problems like addiction may be so stigmatized that open discussion would jeopardize one's personal and professional life. But I've found that people are generally understanding of your shortcomings, particularly when they're revealed in the context of an improvement goal. Anonymity makes your commitment much shallower.

Read More......

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Oh, the irony!

I've been quite liberal in my derision of poor Powerpoint presentations. But Mr. Smarty-Pants stepped in it big-time this week.

I appreciate an excellent presentation. At meetings or rounds, I really enjoy a speaker who has taken the time to put his/her audience first. Who makes sure the audiovisual material is appealing and appropriate. Who checks that all the necessary equipment is available and functional.

I like to give a good presentation. And I cringe when something goes wrong. Like earlier this week.

I was invited to present our Advanced Access project to the annual meeting of the Saskatchewan Association of Health Organizations in Regina. I was excited to be asked and put a lot of work into the presentation.

I used lots of graphics and photos, and kept text to a minimum. (Only one bullet point slide out of 42!) I stuck to 3 main points. I included some video clips to illustrate my points.

And that's where the wheels came off the wagon.

There was no speaker system to amplify the sound from my laptop. It wasn't a big room, but people at the back couldn't hear the clips. What better way to have your audience's attention wander?

To make it worse, one of the themes of my presentation was "It's all about your audience". I was trying to apply the metaphor of a performer and his audience to the concept of patient and family-centred care in our Advanced Access project. I went on and on about how important it is to think about what engages and entertains your audience (or what's important for your patient). Then, I play the video clips and half the audience can't hear them.

Just to balance my karma, another theme was "Do it", meaning, don't be afraid to try new things and fail at them, because it's always a chance to learn from mistakes. This was the first time I'd included a lot of video clips, so it was a nice demonstration of how to screw up when you try something new. Irony was having a field day.

My first inclination was to blame the conference organizers. I'd given them plenty of notice that I needed to plug into an audio system, but nothing was provided. But, I have to take responsibility myself. I've often seen speakers stymied when they couldn't get a computer or projector going, and thought "That's pathetic that you are so reliant on your slides to speak about this topic. You should be prepared for tech glitches." It was my turn to be stymied.

For next time, I'll have to see about getting a small, portable speaker that I can connect to my laptop. Oh, geez, I just had an esprit de l'escalier moment: I should have taken off my lapel mike and laid it on the laptop's speaker!

Anyway, thanks to everyone who was kind enough to come to my presentation. Sorry for the glitch. Try me again and I'll have it fixed.

Read More......

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Would you like whine with that?

I pity the poor medical students who do clinical rotations with me. They have to listen to me complaining non-stop.

They're always polite and attentive about my griping. I hope they don't think their rotation assessment could be affected by the quality of their sympathetic nodding.

When a student is in the office with me, my main topic to moan about is inadequate information in the referral letters I receive. I've blogged about this before. Anyway, a senior medical student just spent a few days with me in the office, and yesterday, I was in mid-kvetch when I thought "I gotta stop whining about this and actually do something about it."

We've had success with sending out a checklist to referring doctors regarding a specific condition (microscopic hematuria). We ask for certain information and test results to be sent along to us, before we see the patient. You can see the letter on our office website.

I'm thinking of a different approach for information on a person's past medical history, medications and allergies. I'll try sending out a questionnaire directly to the patient. After all, it's the same questions they'll answer when they come to see me anyway.

This isn't earth-shattering, I know. It's already done in many offices, whether ahead of time, or as something to be completed when the patient arrives at the office. I'm sure there will be lots of forms and templates I can steal (I mean, collaborate non-consensually). I'm thinking I'll send out 10 trial forms with the patient's appointment letter and ask them to either mail the form back or fax it to me. I'll keep track of who had the forms sent to them and how many are returned.

I'll let you know how it goes.

Read More......

Friday, February 8, 2008

What's wrong with this picture? - X (Med school, Old school)








This lab coat, belonging to a senior medical student, was hanging in the lounge last week. The pockets were stuffed to bursting. In addition to 6 (!!!) reference books (Surgery on call, Internal Medicine on call, etc.), there was a set of critical care flashcards. Geez, buddy, are you part pack mule?

How about trading your collapsed vertebrae in for a PDA? Get some electronic references installed and whip it out when you see your next patient with Dengue fever.

Better yet, convince the College of Medicine to provide access to a standard set of digital reference books (reviewed and approved by faculty) to all medical students. You could use them through any internet connection (ideally wireless via PDA) and they would be updated more regularly than print references.

Read More......

Thursday, January 24, 2008

False positive

My daughter wanted to know about false-positive tests this week. She's a fan of the TV medical drama, House, so I caught a bit of it while I was doing the dishes (you'll have to take my word for it).

An oncologist had to break some disturbing news to a patient. Of course, there was a twist.

The man had been diagnosed with terminal lung cancer, but it turned out that the test was incorrect, i.e false-positive. He didn't have cancer at all. The oncologist expected that the man would be thrilled to hear the news. He wasn't.

The oncologist couldn't understand why the man was upset. Surely he should be overjoyed at having his life sentence lifted!

The problem was that the man had already acted on the false report. He had told his friends the bad news. He had sold his house and spent the money on a trip to Europe. While he was happy that he didn't have cancer, he was not pleased with the profound effect this false alarm had on his life.

A similar situation comes up very commonly in urology practice. Men are often tested for prostate cancer using prostate-specific antigen (PSA). Well, at least they think they're being tested for prostate cancer. The PSA blood test doesn't actually give a yes-or-no answer to this question. It just tells us how suspicious we should be and whether further testing is warranted. The higher the PSA level, the greater the likelihood that prostate cancer is present.

But there's a twist here, too.

Benign prostate enlargement - very common in men over age 50 - also causes the PSA level to rise. In fact, when the PSA is mildly elevated (for example, between 4 and 10), it's more likely that the elevation is due to benign disease rather than cancer, in a 2:1 ratio. That's a lot of false-positives.

The abnormal PSA level leads to further testing, usually a prostate biopsy. This involves inserting a probe into the rectum and using a needle to take samples of the prostate. It's uncomfortable and carries some risk of complications. Also, men with abnormal PSA levels suffer anxiety about the possible cancer diagnosis.

When there is no cancer present (i.e. the PSA level was up because of benign prostate enlargement), the man goes through a needless biopsy and worry. Yet, when I call men about their negative biopsy results, they universally say "Whew, that's good news."

I sometimes wonder why they don't react like the patient on House: "You mean I went through all that worry and that biopsy done for nothing? I never had a problem in the first place. If I hadn't had that PSA test done, I could have been spared all of this. That test was a false alarm!"

When a false-positive test comes back, it means we've taken a healthy person (well, at least, they don't have that particular disease) and put them through stress and further testing that is of no value to them. Many people rationalize this with the old "Better safe than sorry" argument.

Of course, it's up to each man to decide whether he wants to take the chance of having a false-positive result. That means he should be informed of the risks and benefits of PSA screening before being tested. My experience is that most men haven't been informed before testing. Many of them aren't even aware the test was done (usually as part of "routine blood work") until they're called with the abnormal result.

"Better safe than sorry" only holds true if the patient has had the chance to consider how much "sorry" they're willing to accept to be "safe".

Read More......

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Outside the RateMDs box

A member of my spy network reported overhearing some first-year medical students talking about their clinical shadowing.

Medical students are required to spend time with clinicians in order to get a broad exposure to the various medical disciplines. These students were planning to surf RateMDs to check out potential mentors for shadowing!

Brilliant. (Really.)

Most of the comments on RateMDs pertain to the physician's affability and communication skills. When patients are unhappy with a physician, it almost always means that communication has been poor.

As such, if physicians are rated highly on RateMDs, they're likely to be pleasant to spend time with under other circumstances, i.e. clinical shadowing.

Plus, they'll be good role-models. That counts for something, too.

Hey, you kids! How about a mash-up that combines the list of College of Medicine-approved clinicians with their RateMDs profiles? It'd save you time and probably make for some entertaining reading. Let me know when you've whipped it up.

Read More......