I pity the poor medical students who do clinical rotations with me. They have to listen to me complaining non-stop.
They're always polite and attentive about my griping. I hope they don't think their rotation assessment could be affected by the quality of their sympathetic nodding.
When a student is in the office with me, my main topic to moan about is inadequate information in the referral letters I receive. I've blogged about this before. Anyway, a senior medical student just spent a few days with me in the office, and yesterday, I was in mid-kvetch when I thought "I gotta stop whining about this and actually do something about it."
We've had success with sending out a checklist to referring doctors regarding a specific condition (microscopic hematuria). We ask for certain information and test results to be sent along to us, before we see the patient. You can see the letter on our office website.
I'm thinking of a different approach for information on a person's past medical history, medications and allergies. I'll try sending out a questionnaire directly to the patient. After all, it's the same questions they'll answer when they come to see me anyway.
This isn't earth-shattering, I know. It's already done in many offices, whether ahead of time, or as something to be completed when the patient arrives at the office. I'm sure there will be lots of forms and templates I can steal (I mean, collaborate non-consensually). I'm thinking I'll send out 10 trial forms with the patient's appointment letter and ask them to either mail the form back or fax it to me. I'll keep track of who had the forms sent to them and how many are returned.
I'll let you know how it goes.
Thursday, February 14, 2008
Would you like whine with that?
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:58 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Office practice 1 comments
Monday, February 4, 2008
No-show no-no
I received this transcript from a CBC Radio Saskatchewan program:CBC-RADIO, SASK. FEBRUARY 4, 2008. 6:30 HRS.
There could be warning signs at the doctor's office that say you have to pay a charge for missed appointments
PAT HUME [ANNOUNCER]
Don't be surprised if you see warning signs posted on the wall at your next appointment with a medical specialist. Those signs advise patients that if they miss or cancel appointments they could be billed. For skipped appointments the average is between $30 and $50 dollars. For missed procedures the cost is much higher.
Dr. Joe Pfeifer is President of the Saskatchewan Medical Association and a surgeon in Saskatoon. He says in his practice approximately one out of every ten patients misses or cancels appointments each day. Pfeifer says people also skip MRIs, CAT Scan and colonoscopies, procedures with huge waiting lists.
DR. JOE PFEIFER [President - Sask Medical Association]
Patients who do not show for appointments or procedures just create more of a burden on the system. It's a little disappointing that sometimes people have an attitude that is not the most responsible when it comes to health care because it is needy and there is such a shortage of resources and physicians. It's just sad to see them used badly.
PAT HUME [ANNOUNCER]
Under the Saskatchewan Medical Association's guide to uninsured services patients can be billed up to 50% of the cost of the missed appointment or procedure. Pfeifer says his office has seen fewer no-shows since a warning has appeared at the bottom of appointment cards.
Since we started our Advanced Access project last year, I've paid more attention to missed appointments or "no-shows". We've been tracking them regularly. In our practice, there's a 10-15% no-show rate. No-shows are different than cancelled appointments in that we at least get some warning about cancellations. Not so no-shows. They're completely wasted capacity. We don't know about them until after the appointment time has passed.
That's very frustrating for busy physicians who are trying to deal with long wait times. However, I'm disturbed by the tone of the CBC interview. It makes it sound like an adversarial process. Us vs. them. Only bad people miss appointments.
And they should pay a price!
What we have here is a treatment prescribed before a diagnosis is made.
Before laying blame, physicians need to look at the reasons for no-shows. Perhaps the letter announcing the appointment went astray. When that has happened at my office, the patient (or the referring physician) will call after a few weeks to ask when their appointment will be made. My staff will tell them that their appointment date has already passed, and we'll make a new appointment. Sometimes, under those circumstances, the patient will apologize for not attending the first appointment, even though it was our error in not notifying him!
Perhaps the problem is lack of transportation (Saskatchewan is a big place!), a sick child, or another unpredictable event. (Hard as it is to imagine, a doctor's appointment isn't always the most important event in a person's day!)
I'm interested in how no-show's relate to the length of wait between referral date and consultation date. When we started to work on reducing wait times in our office, patients were waiting up to 4 months for appointments. I have trouble remembering appointments 2 weeks from now (ask my wife), let alone 4 months!
Certainly, if you have a medical problem that's painful or debilitating, you'll remember that appointment with the doctor. But some "problems" (such as abnormal lab tests like high PSA levels, or traces of blood in the urine) don't cause symptoms. Pretty easy to forget when you're trying to get a crop off the field.
I wonder what charging for no-shows accomplishes. Perhaps it does reduce no-show rates, but what does it do for physicians' relationships with their patients? Given the relative lack of specialists in Saskatchewan, will some patients feel pressure to pay the fee, even if they had a valid reason for missing the appointment. And, if exceptions are allowed, who's going to judge their validity? I know I already have enough work to do without adding administrative work. I doubt that my office staff would be happy in this role, either.
Although it's certainly inadvertent, the message I get from the CBC piece is that the system is built to suit providers, not patients. Rather than blaming patients for missing appointments, let's try this: Ask what we could do differently to serve them better.
Could we:Let patients choose their own appointment time?
Phone patients with a reminder 48 hours in advance?
Reduce our wait times?
By the way, doc, if you work on reducing your no-show rate, you'll also increase your revenues. (In a more satisfying way than by nickel-and-diming your patients with punitive fees.)
Physician, heal thyself.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
11:16 p.m.
Saturday, January 19, 2008
Holidays on-line
Google does it again! We just moved our office holiday calendar on-line and it is great!
Until this week, all the docs in our practice requested and recorded holidays on a paper calendar. That meant that we had to be at the office to check the calendar and write in our requests.
Now, the paper calendar has been tranferred to Google Calender. Each doc has his/her own holiday calendar, which Google merges onto a master calendar.
My wife and I just decided on a trip we'd like to take. Rather than waiting until I'm back at the office on Monday to book the days off work, I just checked the calendar on-line and submitted my requests by email.
We can also clearly see how many people are away during any given week, in order to avoid leaving the practice short-handed. At year end, tallying up the number of holidays taken will be easier, as each physician's calendar can be reviewed individually.
Easier holiday planning brought to you by Google.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
7:24 p.m.
Labels: Office practice 0 comments
Tuesday, January 1, 2008
New Division of Urology website/blog
The new year sees the launch of a new Saskatoon Division of Urology blog. But you can't see it.
Sorry to be a tease about this, but it's intended for internal communication among our urologists.
I see it as a repository for meeting records, schedules of grand rounds and journal club, call schedules, etc.
As with all new things, the challenge is in selling it. I'll load up the blog with stuff like links to the health region's digital image/X-ray archive, our call schedule, and clinical guidelines. We'll see if the urologists think it's worthwhile.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
11:31 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Office practice 1 comments
Monday, December 31, 2007
Fun Works
I enjoyed reading Fun Works - Creating Places Where People Love To Work by Leslie Yerkes. She suggests that encouraging people to have fun at work reaps benefits of increased productivity, creativity and employee retention. Sounds like a prescription for the healthcare system.
She's not talking about having fun socializing at work (although this is important). She writes about integrating work and fun into a "culture of fun". There are great stories about Pike Place Fish, Harvard University Dining Services and Southwest Airlines. All these businesses emphasize a focus on their customers' experience, and how satisfying and invigorating this can be for employees. Sounds suspiciously like patient/family-centred care...
I was particularly struck by her comments on taking risks in order to "harness and develop the full potential of employees":The integration of fun and work requires expansive thinking and risk taking. When we utilize expansive thinking, we learn to 'think beyond the box.' When our thinking expands, we create the room for fun to come into our work. Only then can we embrace the risk of integrating fun and work.
To embrace risk taking means to try new things without fear of criticism, to be able to make mistakes and welcome them as learning, without fear of punishment. To be successful at risk taking, we must overcome our fear of failure; we must be able to bring our whole selves to work without fear of rejection. Once we are successful at expansive thinking, risk taking itself becomes fun.
Nothing great in history was ever accomplished without risk. The risk for great success is the same as the risk for failure - extremely high; the risk involved in producing mediocrity is extremely low. To succeed greatly, we must risk greatly. (My emphasis) Risk is inherent in innovation and innovation is the life-blood of our future. Lead the way into the future - don't follow.
Expand your thinking, embrace the risk of fun and work.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
9:44 p.m.
Labels: Office practice, Quality Improvement 1 comments
Tuesday, December 18, 2007
Who was that masked man?
Wow! I had no idea how many blogger docs were out there until I started poking around in Medicine 2.0. But what's with the anonymity?
I agree with Jay Parkinson - if you're a professional and have something to say about your profession, why not put your name on it? If it's controversial, be ready to support your opinion. If it's offensive, don't post it. Sooner or later, you're going to get outed. It just depends on how badly someone wants to find out who you really are.
I cringed recently while reading a post on Urostream, by keagirl, an anonymous urologist from "A Big City, USA". I generally enjoy this blog, but this time, she lists various euphemisms used in office notes to disguise what she is really saying about a patient.
Use these puppies at your own risk, keagirl! If one of your patients asks for a copy of her records, how will you explain what you meant when you called her "challenging and loquacious". Maybe you could bafflegab her, but what about her lawyer? A judge? Professional review board? Especially when you've published a glossary on the internet.
I guess that's why anonymity is so important.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:48 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Office practice 0 comments
Sunday, December 16, 2007
Still like the Skype
Since starting to use Skype last month, I'm still very pleased with the service. I made 2 discoveries last week.
First, Skype's customer service seems very good. I had a glitch using Skype on my laptop. (Of course, it turned out to be my mistake, but let's not dwell on that.) Their online help desk sorted out my problem within 24 hours.
Second, I found out that Skype shows your Skype username to people with call display on their phones. That explained why, over the last few weeks, when I've called some people on Skype, they seemed suspicious of who was calling. I indicated it was "Dr. Visvanathan calling with test results", but they didn't seem to believe me. They were expecting to see my full name on call display. (My Skype name is "kishorevis".)
One patient who I eventually reached after several attempts told me he had seen "kishorevis" on his phone and was a bit puzzled. A resourceful chap, he googled it and Plain Brown Wrapper was at the top of the result list. He saw my picture/profile and solved his mystery. Perhaps a sneaky way to publicize one's blog!
Beware if you're in the habit of choosing "naughty" usernames, especially if you're using Skype for business. First impressions...
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:48 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Office practice 0 comments
Thursday, December 6, 2007
Advanced Access in Qreview
HQC Qreview newsletter has an article about our Advanced Access project.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:34 a.m.
Monday, December 3, 2007
EHR? ASAP!
Canada Health Infoway promoted electronic health records (EHR) in the Globe and Mail this weekend (online here). CEO Richard Alvarez says Canadians should "demand" EHRs. If the public only knew how ridiculously wasteful the current system is, "demand" would be putting it lightly.
I've explored the concept of muda in my Advanced Access blog, but here's some examples of wasted time, energy and money from one day in my practice.
7 a.m. hospital rounds: 4 patients to discharge after prostate surgery. Same instructions written out manually on 4 charts. An electronic system would allow routine orders to be bundled together and added to a patient's digital chart with a single mouse click. (Please let me log into this system with a fingerprint or retinal scan. Don't make me go through password purgatory!)
A man with blood in his urine needs a kidney ultrasound. I fill out the requisition and indicate the clinical problem. Hope the radiologist can read my handwriting. Once again, common tasks should be automated.
8 a.m. Seeing a man with a kidney stone. He had an X-ray done yesterday in his home town, 1.5 hours away. I have a verbal report, but his doctor didn't send the films so I can't review the study myself. Our new PACS (on-line X-ray storage system) went live last week, so I can access any films done in Saskatoon, but it doesn't give province-wide access yet. I have to repeat the X-ray in order to make a diagnosis and recommend treatment. Muda tally: Waste of his time, my time, X-ray technologist's time, extra dose of X-rays and cost to the taxpayer.
10 a.m. Elderly man referred to see me because he's having difficulty passing his urine. Family doctor's letter is, shall we say, brief. No indication of other medical history, medications, allergies or results of previous tests. I ask about his medications. He's on a blue pill and a little white one. No idea what the names are. Helpfully, he says that his doctor should have a record of all his pills. No doubt his doctor does. A universal EHR would mean I could access all his history, medications and test results instantly, saving time and reducing chance for mistakes or faulty memory.
11 a.m Review lab results received today. We use an electronic medical record program in our office. (It's basic, but is a huge improvement over hunting through paper charts.) Our health region's lab has its results in electronic form. Sounds like a match made in heaven, huh? Hey, Lab, why don't you just electronic those results right over to us?
Well, they can't. Actually, they can, because they do it for other doctors' offices in our region, but they can't do it for us. I've asked several times and the reason seems to be that they don't have the proper (insert random, unconvincing technobabble here) for our program and we'll just have to wait our turn to get connected. It's been about 2 years now.
In the meantime, they fax us the results and we scan them into our system. It's a crazy Rube Goldberg machine. Not only does this waste my staff's time, there's a huge opportunity cost. Because the lab results only exist in our system as scanned pictures, the system doesn't really "know" what the results are. We can't follow results (such as PSA levels) over time without having to manually enter every single result. We can't search for abnormal results. We could be doing so much more with this information.
These examples are just about shuffling data around. That's peanuts! An EHR could harness computer-assisted decision-making, show current evidence-based best practice, alert me to medication interactions, help patients be more informed and involved in their care, the list goes on...
I want my EHR!
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:15 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Electronic health records, Office practice, Quality Improvement 3 comments
Wednesday, November 14, 2007
Yes to Skype!
Two weeks ago, one of my partners suggested we start using Skype at the office for our long-distance calls. Gold star to you, doctor!
Skype is one of several VoIP services that let you place phone calls over the internet. You need a USB headset/microphone connected to your computer and a Skype account. You can call from your computer to another computer for free. If you want to call from your computer to a telephone (handy!), you have to pay. Well, if you call $30 a year, "paying"! (Unlimited calls within North America.)
We spend many thousands of dollars a year on long-distance calls, as many of our patients and referring physicians live outside urban Saskatoon. If Skype works for us, we'll be saving plenty.
I've been using it for the last week and it has been very good. There are the occasional calls with poor quality, but almost all the calls are crystal clear. I've also occasionally found that the system doesn't always let both people talk at once and there are sometimes voice delays. These are the exception, however.
Also, I can use Skype wherever I have my laptop and a wireless network. I can make long-distance calls at the hospital (or from home) without having to bill the office calling card.
I'm going to continue the trial for a few more weeks, but so far, Skype gets high marks.
Posted by
Kishore Visvanathan
at
10:22 p.m.
Labels: Communication, Office practice 1 comments