Showing posts with label Quality Improvement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Quality Improvement. Show all posts

Sunday, March 7, 2010

Budget cut blues

My HQC blog has moved to Blogger to join Plain Brown Wrapper.
The Sask. budget is coming down in a few weeks, and I'm already worried about QI drawing the short straw.

Read More......

Thursday, March 19, 2009

Surgical checklists hit the big screen!

Well, almost. The ever-topical TV show, ER, featured surgical checklists in a recent episode. If that's what it takes to get the momentum going on implementation of checklists, I'm OK with that. Pressure and interest from the public will be a very powerful force to convince recalcitrant OR staff. (And, when I say recalcitrant OR staff, I think you know who I'm talking about.)

Read More......

Sunday, March 1, 2009

'Difficult' patients

Want to know what patient-centred/patient-directed care could look like? Read "On being a 'Difficult' Patient" by Michelle Mayer.

Then, if you have some time, and a box of Kleenex, go to her blog "Portrait of a Dying Mom".

Read More......

Thursday, November 27, 2008

More RateMD fodder

Here's a recent article from the Prairie Post. 1762 Sask docs listed on RateMD. There is no escape!

Read More......

Sunday, August 3, 2008

Tom Peters takes on Health Care

Tom Peters (Re-Imagine) is just a little hot about Health Care. Check out his proposed hospital org chart.

He gets it.

Read More......

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

Warts and all

Dan Walter put a comment on my last post, and it's left me a bit of a dilemma.

He comments that he's "off topic", and, after I did a little homework/surfing, I think he's right. In fact, his post is essentially spam to promote his website/agenda.

And an angry agenda it is!

Dan has left a link to Adventures in Cardiology which is a bitter-voiced (and perhaps rightly so...) personal account of medical misadventures (yes, that's a euphemism!).

So, what should I do with his comment, which had nothing to do with my post about Powerpoint presentations? My first thought was to just delete the comment and have done with it. Obviously, he wants to draw a wide audience to his website to hear his story. How much of the story is accurate? The tone he takes is aggressively negative ("mangled", "ripped to shreds", "bumbling cardiology staff", "Warfarin is commonly used as rat poison") and, frankly, off-putting.

My immediate, visceral impression was to write him off as a crank. He comes across as an angry man who's more interested in trashing, rather than improving, the system.

But, maybe there's some lessons to be learned here (curse you, cooler, contemplative side of my brain!). If medical staff truly made the mistakes Dan chronicles, then the next steps post-error were most critical in moving on: honesty, communication and transparency. Our provincial licensing body repeated tells us that most complaints lodged against physicians are on the basis of poor communication, whether or not there was any medical misadventure. From Dan's story, it sounds like this was a big part of the problem, compounding the actual medical complications.

Even if the medical team weren't "responsible" for any of the misfortune Dan has described, the system has nonetheless failed him and his family. After all, if we want to consider that we practice "Patient/Client and Family-Centred Care" (PFCC), then it is our patients/clients who get to decide whether or not they are satisfied with the results.

Their satisfaction will be based primarily not on the outcome measures favored by the healthcare system (mortality, infection rates, length of stay), but on their experience in the system. Were they treated with respect and dignity? Were they invited to participate in decision-making to the level they wished? Was all pertinent information shared promptly, freely and in a format that the patient and family could understand and use in collaborative decision-making?

And so, Dan's link remains on my blog. If you do check out his site , try this experiment: Read it first from the point of view of a health professional dealing with this "difficult and demanding" family member. Think about how you would cringe, and look for an escape-route, if you saw Dan coming down the hallway of your hospital ward. What a jerk this guy is! He just doesn't understand the complexity of problems we're dealing with every day.

(As I noted above, this circle-the-wagons approach was my first instinct.)

Then try looking through a "customer-service" lens: I want to provide each client with an excellent experience that will reflect well on me personally, my profession and my institution. How can I change the system (yes, I can!) to serve Dan and his family better?

BTW, it's an open-book quiz - the answers are all here.

Read More......

Thursday, May 29, 2008

Complications

As I started reading Atul Gawande's Complications: A Surgeon's Notes on an Imperfect Science, my first reaction was Nooooo! Don't give away the secrets!

When relating his first attempts at an invasive procedure (central venous catheter insertion), Gawande is so frank about his uncertainty and shortcomings, that it made me squirm to recall my own similar experiences.

All physicians gain experience through practice - on real, live patients. This practice, during residency, is supervised by senior attending physicians. However, as Gawande points out, the degree and proximity of supervision varies according to circumstance.

How do we balance being honest about our level of expertise against wanting to spare patients unnecessary anxiety? How can residents learn a new procedure if they don't perform it on a patient?

Gawande explores these questions with astonishing openness. Plus, he's a great storyteller. His story of the failed tracheostomy (lost airway, anyone?) made me cringe.

Non-physicians read this book at your own peril. You may dispel the myth of the infallible surgeon.

Read More......

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Healthcare efficiency

Interesting post on "Healthcare Efficiency" (April 17) about preventing hospital acquired infections in the US. Love the last paragraph about healthcare workers resistance to the ideas behind Quality Improvement and change (? Change) in general.

Read More......

Sunday, April 20, 2008

Blogging to a better you

This Globe and Mail article struck a chord with me. While I haven't been blogging about the intimate topics (personal financial disasters, obesity/weight loss) discussed, I have had some of the same thoughts expressed by the bloggers interviewed.

The article's theme is: Making your personal goals public will boost your resolve.

A small example in Plain Brown Wrapper was my New Year's resolution to wear my name tag at work. I'm sure no one at the hospital reads PBW, but the possibility that someone might catch me without my tag and comment "Didn't I read your blog..." was a motivator. I've been pretty consistent in wearing it.

My Advanced Access blog has put our project into the public eye. We get about 700 hits every 2 weeks. Just knowing that so many people are following our progress keeps me focussed and excited about the project.

I agreed with many quotes in the G&M article, like "... she receives some of the best feedback from readers when she posts entries that make her feel vulnerable." and "... blogging is not for the faint of heart."

But, I take issue with "Openly failing, however, is a blog risk... many bloggers opt for anonymity." Certainly, some problems like addiction may be so stigmatized that open discussion would jeopardize one's personal and professional life. But I've found that people are generally understanding of your shortcomings, particularly when they're revealed in the context of an improvement goal. Anonymity makes your commitment much shallower.

Read More......

Monday, April 7, 2008

Front page news! Engineering techniques improve health care.

This wasn't on the front page of the Globe and Mail, but it should have been! Check out the examples of "using math and technology to re-engineer how the system works".

Read More......

Sunday, March 2, 2008

Help wanted? (What's wrong with this picture? - XI)

The Canadian Medical Association is running a Help Wanted campaign to convince politicians and the public that Canada needs more doctors.

Here's the eye-catching ad that ran in the Globe and Mail yesterday:




Earlier in the week, I received a CMA mail-out containing a postcard. There was an exhortation to mail the postcard to the Prime Minister to draw his attention to Canada's physician shortage.

I didn't mail it.

Some times I ignore similar calls for political action purely out of apathy. This time, it's a stand on principle. I reject the premise that having more doctors will solve problems of access and quality in Canadian healthcare.

It may be part of the answer, but this campaign (see "alarming facts") ignores some broader issues.

"Do it yourself?" over the picture of a man suturing his own wound is a dramatic demonstration that some medical care should be provided by trained professionals (pace Rambo). But, is there an opportunity to educate patients to manage aspects of their care that currently "require" a physician? Why not DIY?

Most diabetics manage their own insulin to control their blood sugar. We trust patients to self-administer their prescription meds. What other "medical" duties can we educate our patients to perform? Can other personnel free up physicians to do the tasks that truly require their expertise?

The "More doctors. More care." slogan suggests that we're doing a great job already; we just need to more of it. There's remarkably little nuance to this argument.

What if we're not operating at maximum efficacy? If we crank up the number of practitioners, we'll multiply waste and poor quality.

Please note that I ask about operating at maximum efficacy , not efficiency. Many physicians are already putting in long hours and would find it difficult to work harder/more efficiently. But what are the outcomes of those long hours? Are we making a positive impact on chronic disease? How often do we really need to review the stable hypertensive's blood pressure? Or, in my practice, the man with an undetectable PSA after he's had surgery for prostate cancer?

Are we even asking ourselves these questions, or are we completely occupied with the struggle to keep our heads above the ceaseless demand for medical services?

Over the last year in my office, we've reevaluated many
of our practices/traditions/habits as part of our Advanced Access practice. Many of our procedures don't add value for our patients, and (by definition) are wasteful to the system. We're trying to change, but it's challenging, given the demands of a busy surgical practice. And (let's not ignore the 800 lb. gorilla in the room) the absence of fee-for-service remuneration for quality improvement efforts.

How much waste could be trimmed if the CMA put some of its "Help wanted" budget into quality improvement training, mentoring and support for physicians? How much physician time would this free up for additional patient care?

Dr. Day, show me some creativity beyond the sledgehammer approach of expanding the physician workforce.

Then, maybe I'll sign your postcard.




Read More......

Saturday, January 12, 2008

What's wrong with this picture? - X

Today's WWWTP is a new post, Darwin's Cystoscope, at Adventures in Advanced Access.

Read More......

Wednesday, January 9, 2008

Whoa to checklists?

Atul Gawande's at it again. Check out this NY Times op-ed about how bureaucracy shut down a successful program that reduced central line sepsis.

Excellent clinical care is no longer possible without doctors and nurses routinely using checklists and other organizational strategies and studying their results.

- Gawande


Read More......

Tuesday, January 8, 2008

Mmmm... Checklists!

More on the yummy goodness of checklists (c/o Atul Gawande).

Read More......

Monday, December 31, 2007

Fun Works

I enjoyed reading Fun Works - Creating Places Where People Love To Work by Leslie Yerkes. She suggests that encouraging people to have fun at work reaps benefits of increased productivity, creativity and employee retention. Sounds like a prescription for the healthcare system.

She's not talking about having fun socializing at work (although this is important). She writes about integrating work and fun into a "culture of fun". There are great stories about Pike Place Fish, Harvard University Dining Services and Southwest Airlines. All these businesses emphasize a focus on their customers' experience, and how satisfying and invigorating this can be for employees. Sounds suspiciously like patient/family-centred care...

I was particularly struck by her comments on taking risks in order to "harness and develop the full potential of employees":

The integration of fun and work requires expansive thinking and risk taking. When we utilize expansive thinking, we learn to 'think beyond the box.' When our thinking expands, we create the room for fun to come into our work. Only then can we embrace the risk of integrating fun and work.

To embrace risk taking means to try new things without fear of criticism, to be able to make mistakes and welcome them as learning, without fear of punishment. To be successful at risk taking, we must overcome our fear of failure; we must be able to bring our whole selves to work without fear of rejection. Once we are successful at expansive thinking, risk taking itself becomes fun.

Nothing great in history was ever accomplished without risk. The risk for great success is the same as the risk for failure - extremely high; the risk involved in producing mediocrity is extremely low. To succeed greatly, we must risk greatly. (My emphasis) Risk is inherent in innovation and innovation is the life-blood of our future. Lead the way into the future - don't follow.

Expand your thinking, embrace the risk of fun and work.



Read More......

Monday, December 3, 2007

EHR? ASAP!

Canada Health Infoway promoted electronic health records (EHR) in the Globe and Mail this weekend (online here). CEO Richard Alvarez says Canadians should "demand" EHRs. If the public only knew how ridiculously wasteful the current system is, "demand" would be putting it lightly.

I've explored the concept of muda in my Advanced Access blog, but here's some examples of wasted time, energy and money from one day in my practice.

7 a.m. hospital rounds: 4 patients to discharge after prostate surgery. Same instructions written out manually on 4 charts. An electronic system would allow routine orders to be bundled together and added to a patient's digital chart with a single mouse click. (Please let me log into this system with a fingerprint or retinal scan. Don't make me go through password purgatory!)

A man with blood in his urine needs a kidney ultrasound. I fill out the requisition and indicate the clinical problem. Hope the radiologist can read my handwriting. Once again, common tasks should be automated.

8 a.m. Seeing a man with a kidney stone. He had an X-ray done yesterday in his home town, 1.5 hours away. I have a verbal report, but his doctor didn't send the films so I can't review the study myself. Our new PACS (on-line X-ray storage system) went live last week, so I can access any films done in Saskatoon, but it doesn't give province-wide access yet. I have to repeat the X-ray in order to make a diagnosis and recommend treatment. Muda tally: Waste of his time, my time, X-ray technologist's time, extra dose of X-rays and cost to the taxpayer.

10 a.m. Elderly man referred to see me because he's having difficulty passing his urine. Family doctor's letter is, shall we say, brief. No indication of other medical history, medications, allergies or results of previous tests. I ask about his medications. He's on a blue pill and a little white one. No idea what the names are. Helpfully, he says that his doctor should have a record of all his pills. No doubt his doctor does. A universal EHR would mean I could access all his history, medications and test results instantly, saving time and reducing chance for mistakes or faulty memory.

11 a.m Review lab results received today. We use an electronic medical record program in our office. (It's basic, but is a huge improvement over hunting through paper charts.) Our health region's lab has its results in electronic form. Sounds like a match made in heaven, huh? Hey, Lab, why don't you just electronic those results right over to us?

Well, they can't. Actually, they can, because they do it for other doctors' offices in our region, but they can't do it for us. I've asked several times and the reason seems to be that they don't have the proper (insert random, unconvincing technobabble here) for our program and we'll just have to wait our turn to get connected. It's been about 2 years now.

In the meantime, they fax us the results and we scan them into our system. It's a crazy Rube Goldberg machine. Not only does this waste my staff's time, there's a huge opportunity cost. Because the lab results only exist in our system as scanned pictures, the system doesn't really "know" what the results are. We can't follow results (such as PSA levels) over time without having to manually enter every single result. We can't search for abnormal results. We could be doing so much more with this information.

These examples are just about shuffling data around. That's peanuts! An EHR could harness computer-assisted decision-making, show current evidence-based best practice, alert me to medication interactions, help patients be more informed and involved in their care, the list goes on...

I want my EHR!








Read More......

Sunday, October 28, 2007

What's wrong with this picture? - II



Here's a close-up:




This is photo from the OR change room, but I've seen the same sign in many places around the hospital. I understand the problem: Laundry bag too full = heavy weight = back injury. But is this sign the best solution?

Rather than relying on people not to overfill the bags, we need to change the system so they can't overfill the bags. How about using smaller bags? Of course, the bags will need to be changed more often, or more bags need to be in place so laundry doesn't overflow onto the floor.

See the previous "What's wrong with this picture?". There's a pattern here. I'll keep an eye out for other examples and report back to you.


Read More......

Monday, October 22, 2007

What's wrong with this picture?


Here's a close-up:



This is a door at one of our local health facilities. By the presence of the fancy electronic lock, you might imagine that there's a reason to keep unauthorized personnel out. Alas, the door doesn't reliable close on its own, so we're relying on people to remember to pull the door closed manually.



Here's the other side of the door. No sign! So if you're on the way out, you won't be reminded.

Shouldn't the sign on this door read: Attention: Maintenance! Please fix this door. (?)


Read More......

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

RateMDs: Saint or Satan?

Physicians who know about RateMDs are rarely neutral about it. Physicians who don't know about RateMDs... well, watch out, docs!

RateMDs is an online information exchange where anyone can anonymously post comments about a (North American) physician. There are similar sites for rating lawyers, high school teachers, university profs, etc.

RateMDs sparked my online patient satisfaction survey. Here's why:


Physician rating sites have existed as long as there have been physicians. These sites used to be called coffee row, the backyard fence, and your cousin's friend who knows someone who knows someone. The information was there, but was informal and relatively inaccessible unless you were "connected". Now, the Internet makes everyone connected, and they're sharing information.

Browse through RateMDs (c'mon, you know you want to), and you'll see why some physicians are upset about being rated. There are some pretty frank comments. Some may be accurate and deserved. Others may be vindictive and slanderous. We have no way of knowing. Perhaps looking at the pattern of comments gives a reliable picture of each physician's demeanor. I'd like to think so, but comments and ratings for individual physicians vary quite widely in some cases. One person with a vendetta could leave multiple posts slagging the doc. A physician could salt his own page with glowing praise.

There are weaknesses with the RateMDs model, but the idea is here to stay. I think we should embrace the idea, improve the model and turn it to the benefit of our patients. After all, what physician doesn't want honest, frank feedback on his or her performance?

Ha, ha! Of course, I'm being facetious! I'm a lot more comfortable not hearing about my weaknesses and bad habits, and I'm sure many other physicians feel the same way. If I know my performance is substandard, the logical and professional response is: try to improve. And that means... Change! Before physicians decide to ask for feedback from our patients, we need to commit to making the changes that the responses suggest.

I want to solicit patients' opinions about my performance, but I also want to draw on their experience and insight to make constructive suggestions on how I can improve. To that end, I made my own post (April 17, 2007) on RateMDs encouraging people to comment on how I can improve my medical practice.

As you see on my RateMDs page, there haven't been many responses to that request. As such, I decided to start my own personal rating service. I'm requesting patients to take a web-based survey about their experience in my office. In the spirit of openness, I'll post a link to the survey responses on my blog.

How can you be sure that I haven't polished up or even completely faked the survey results? Right now, you can't. But, I welcome any suggestions on how I could set this up so I can't be accused of fabricating results. (At the moment, I feel I need to review the responses before posting them just in case a patient has included private personal or medical information that should not become public knowledge.)


Any suggestions?



Read More......